Unorthodox Pies

Do you know what you're feeding everyone for Thanksgiving yet?  Don't feel bad--you're not alone.  I caught a lucky break this year, personally--my aunt and uncle are having everybody over to their place in Vermont.  That means some fabulous Chinese food (maybe the pork shoulder with carrots, if we're lucky), a lot of chatty catching-up among the girl cousins, and not a single person who actually cares whether there's a turkey or not.  My job? Pies.

Southern_piesNow, if your job is pies, too, you're in luck.  Pie books abound these days--  Nancie McDermott's new one, Southern Pies, has a dizzy selection (spicy peanut! green tomato!)--but there's also gluten-free pies, high-altitude pies, even whoopie pies.  All this means that if you check your EYB Bookshelf, like I did--you've probably got hundreds of pie recipes.  My Bookshelf has 3,325.  But I actually only need 4.

I'm sorry to say I can take or leave the traditional Thanksgiving pies--pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie, pecan pie.  I'm sure there's a good time and place for them--after you've been skiing all day, say, and you're a mite peckish.  But after the gastronomic blowout that is Thanksgiving?  Your typical 4000-calorie pecan pie elicits nothing but groans, and for good reason.

So here's where I am right now:  Pie 1: Apple pie, with local heirloom apples and the failproof pie crust from Jeffrey Steingarten's The Man Who Ate Everything.
Pie 2: Very Cranberry-Pear Pie, which I just found with a search for "cranberries," in the "Pies, Tarts, & Pastries" category.  It's in Ken Haedrich's Pie.
Pie 3 will be Sherry Yard's Deep dark chocolate tart, from Secrets of Baking.  I know, I know, not a pie, but some of us just can't do without our chocolate.  I'm hoping everyone will be too stuffed with pork to notice.

That leaves me with Pie 4, which is, right now, a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma.  How about it, EYB friends?  Got a favorite pie--or non-pie--you think everyone should know about?   Talk to me - leave a comment!

I'll be back after Turkey (or Whatever) Day with a full report.  Meantime, enjoy your holidays, everybody--down to the last crumb.

4 Comments

  • Lee Jackson  on  12/16/2010 at 10:17 PM

    Can we have a follow-up to your pie baking session?? Thanks.

  • robin Ferrara Singer  on  12/16/2010 at 11:16 PM

    Wondering what the last pie turned out to be. I actually was commissioned to make a banana cream pie. Which is not your typical thanksgiving pie but I gave in and it was fabulous !

  • Kringler  on  12/17/2010 at 5:23 PM

    My great aunt Dora's Cranberry Chiffon Pie is gorgeous, light, and delicious. I sometimes make it in a retangular tart pan instead of a pie pan.

  • Susie  on  12/20/2010 at 8:47 AM

    Friends, sorry for the slow reply! The final pie was the sweet potato pie from Matt Lee and Ted Lee's Lee Bros. Southern Cookbook. I don't usually like sweet potato pies, but this one's special--very light and fluffy. The Cranberry Pear Orange pie from Haedrich's PIE was great too (Kringler, would love the recipe for your aunt Dora's pie, it sounds delicious!) I had some crust snafus, even after all these years of making crust. But hey, we're only human. The thing is, I actually was too stuffed with pork shoulder to eat much at all!

Post a comment

Seen anything interesting? Let us know & we'll share it!

Archives