Roundup season

I love this time of year, and not just because of the cool air and the glowing woodstove.  No, what's special about early November is that it's Holiday Roundup season, when I get to pick the top 10 cookbooks of the year for NPR.  (I also do the Boston Globe's roundup, which tends to vary a bit more in number and in theme.)

From the moment I send out the deadline for submissions, the circus begins.  Within 24 hours, SWAT teams of FedEx and UPS agents are showing up with boxes which thunk heavily, one by one, onto my doorstep.  I grab a box cutter and start opening, piling, and sorting on the kitchen floor.  I'm always a little choked up when I see these stacks of riches--the hard work of thousands of cooks, authors, teachers, writers, and editors-- piled up in tangible form.

But then the hard work begins: testing.  I get books all year, and some have been short-listed from the moment of their first, compelling recipe test. But now is the time for me to pull out all the Post-its (I halve them with a paper cutter to double the yield) and start flagging everything in sight.

Although I know I won't be able to test every book, or even just the most representative recipe from each, I do my best to try a wide selection.  Every night, we eat something completely different.  A typical week from last year (I keep a database to keep track of these): calamari pasta; gigot à la Provençal, brisket with ginger, orange, and tomato; chard walnut lasagna; noodle kugel; potato-turnip purée, South Indian vegetable curry.  I do a lot more baking, so the dessert cookbooks can get their audition, too.

In fact, November roundup testing is almost exclusively responsible for those 10 winter pounds I have to sweat off in the garden 6 months later.  (At the peak of testing, the treadmill is usually covered with cookbooks too!) But I'm not complaining.  I know I'm lucky to be a cookbook reviewer, and my family's lucky I am, too.

Do you have a favorite recipe from this year's cookbooks?  I do!  but I'm not allowed to say.  At least not quite yet.


  • Jane  on  11/7/2011 at 3:51 PM

    I didn't have to think hard about this. The recipe I have cooked repeatedly since I got Melissa Clark's 'Cook This Now' is 'Cumin seed roasted cauliflower with salted yogurt, mint and pomegranate seeds'. I made it for lunch yesterday and I'm planning on having it again tomorrow. As addictions go, thank goodness this one is good for me.

  • leduesorelle  on  11/8/2011 at 8:50 AM

    The two new cookbooks that I've been returning to repeatedly this year are "Plenty" by Yotam Ottolenghi, and "Cooking in the Moment" by Andrea Reusing. If I had to pick a favorite recipe, Reusing's "Old-Fashioned Baked Beans with Smoked Bacon" is it, though I can't to have the chance to try "Campfire Bacon & Eggs in a Bag" sometime. It's mpossible to pick a favorite from "Plenty", each recipe I've tried so far has been a winner. And do the Canal House cookbooks count?

  • BettyC  on  11/9/2011 at 3:54 PM

    Roundup season sounds like a lot of hard work, but what fun! Good luck with your list, and good eating...

  • wester  on  11/10/2011 at 3:09 AM

    I don't usually buy cookbooks in the year they were published, as I find they are too expensive then. My cookbook addiction is more affordable when I wait a bit for someone to offer them up for swapping, or occasionally get one on Amazon when they become cheaper there. That said, Melissa Clark's cauliflower is definitely amazing! Smitten kitchen has the recipe too, that's where I found it. My favourite recipe from a recently acquired book has to be Warm smoked fish and sausage salad, from the River Cottage Fish book. An excellent combination of flavors that I wouldn't have thought of myself.

Post a comment

You may only comment on the blog if you are signed in. Sign In

Seen anything interesting? Let us know & we'll share it!