The world's largest cookbook collection

cookbooks

Longtime Members of EYB may recall our interview in mid-2013 of EYB Member Sue Jimenez, who was at the time attempting to claim the world record for largest cookbook collection. In July 2013 she got the record, with an official tally of 2,970 (which shot up to 3,693 by that November). Sue remains the Guinness World Record holder for largest cookbook collection, and as Serious Eats explains, her current (unofficial) total is nearly 6,400 cookbooks! She frequently blogs about her collection at The Vintage Cookbookery, where she researches cookbooks for history, cultural and social trends, fads, technological changes, and much more.

In her interview with Serious Eats, Sue discusses how her collection began, and how it grew to be so large. When she was 18, her parents started her on this journey by giving her the entire  Time-Life Foods of the World series. She recalls making her first recipe, a cherry strudel, from the German volume. 

Sue points out that her current massive repository is actually her second cookbook collection. At one point she had about 800 books that she acquired from estate sales, thrift shops, and used-book stores. She collected these with the intention of selling them at a profit, but that didn't pan out so she donated them to a local library group. A few months later, Sue noticed that the group was selling the books, and says "My spouse had to practically tie me down to calm my panic at seeing my beloved books going to other homes, and to stop me from rushing down to re-purchase them."

She started collecting cookbooks again a few years later, and hasn't stopped since. Again, she purchased most of them from used-book stores and thrift shops, plus Edward Hamilton Bookshop, a remainder bookstore in Connecticut. Once her collection passed 1,000 books, Sue explains what happened next: "Having passed a neat, round number, I felt obligated to continue to the next neat, round number of 2,000. I promised my husband I would stop then. Well, you can figure out the rest." 

The photo above is one that Sue shared with us in 2013 - the Serious Eats article linked above provides a more recent image of one of the two rooms in her house that is filled with cookbooks. She and her husband moved to a bigger place to accommodate all of their books; her husband also has a collection (mostly science books) although it isn't as large as Sue's. She estimates that between them, they have about 9,000 books, or "enough to start up a small-town library." Of her 6,300+ cookbooks, Sue has 5,357 on her EYB Bookshelf.

Pastry chefs choose the best baking cookbooks

 Best baking books

I don't know about you, but I'm a sucker for lists - especially lists about cookbooks. That's why I honed in on The Strategist's article about the best baking books as selected by pastry chefs. Nine top U.S. pastry chefs and professional bakers were asked to give their opinions on which books were the best in several categories. Some of the selections were expected, but there were a few surprises as well. 

Several of the bakers weighing in have written cookbooks, including Agatha Kulaga and Erin Patinkin of Ovenly; Zachary Golper, chef and owner of Bien Cuit; and Alison Pray, co-owner at Standard Baking Co. in Portland, Maine. The first category, best book for non-bakers, left me scratching my head: the chefs selected Brooks Headley's Fancy Desserts: The Recipes of Del Posto's James Beard Award-Winning Pastry Chef. If I hadn't done any baking, I think I would have found the recipes intimidating, although it is a great read and a wonderful resource. I just don't think that I would give it to someone who wasn't already a baker. 

Other choices made more sense. The best book for beginners was The Baking Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum. All of Beranbaum's books garnered high praise from the chefs, including Miro Uskokovic, pastry chef at Gramercy Tavern in New York. Although it is difficult for him to choose just one, he recommends The Baking Bible for a more general overview of baking and pastry. "You know she tested these recipes time and time again, and it's written in such detail that anyone will be able to execute them," he says.  

Beranbaum's The Cake Bible was chosen as the best book of cake recipes. Strangely, there was no best pie book, an unfortunate oversight, because pie deserves its own category. According to the numbers on EYB Members' Bookshelves, that honor would go to The Pie and Pastry Bible, with the more recent Art of the Pie: A Practical Guide to Homemade Crusts, Fillings, and Life running second.

But I digress. The volume chosen as the best baking book for intermediate bakers was Tartine: Sweet and Savory Pastries, Tarts, Pies, Cakes, Croissants, Cookies and Confections by Elizabeth Prueitt and Chad Robertson. Again, this was a solid choice, although I am also fond of Bouchon Bakery.

Turning to bread, the best for beginners honor went to Bread: A Baker's Book of Techniques and Recipes by Jeffrey Hamelman, while the nod for best book for advanced bakers was Michel Suas's Advanced Bread and Pastry: A Professional Approach. Looks like another book just went into my Amazon cart.

One category name was a bit unorthodox: best desserts cookbook with simple, seasonal recipes. However, the selection was anything but unorthodox, as Claudia Fleming's The Last Course rightly earned the praise here. As Agatha Kulaga says, "These perfect desserts will make you feel like you are the most accomplished pastry chef in the world without ever having to go to culinary school." The Last Course has been out of print for some time and increasingly difficult to find for a reasonable price, but that is about to change as the book is being reissued soon. 

Since these lists always leave room for dissent, I'm going to add a couple of books and authors that I think deserve to be mentioned when talking about best baking books. The first of my favorites is Sweet Miniatures: The Art of Making Bite-Size Desserts by the late Flo Braker. Although not every recipe is a winner, there are plenty of keepers here, along with good advice on how to make small treats that are perfect for parties. For bread basics, my go-to has been The Bread Baker's Apprentice: Mastering the Art of Extraordinary Bread by Peter Reinhart. It provides a solid foundation for understanding the many variables that go into making a loaf, from lean artisan breads to buttery, enriched ones like brioche. 

Dorie Greenspan also merits inclusion in at least one of the categories - or perhaps they could have added one for best cookie book. Greenspan's books are favorites of EYB Members, and with good reason. Greenspan's directions are clear and concise, and she guides bakers gently but firmly into achieving good results. She also allows you room to play and grow, suggesting adaptations to her recipes to achieve different effects. You can't go wrong with Baking Chez Moi: Recipes from My Paris Home to Your Home AnywhereBaking: From My Home to Yours, and of course Dorie's Cookies.

I think that Stella Parks is poised to become the muse of a new generation of bakers. BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts has been a revelation, and I'm sure it's just the beginning for the talented Parks, who combines her scientific approach with a quick wit that makes her recipes come alive. 

Given the judges, this list is slanted to U.S. books and authors, but I would be remiss not to mention Nigella Lawson's How To Be a Domestic Goddess: Baking and the Art of Comfort Food (UK), and of course the book that many of us immediately fell in love with, Sweet by Yotam Ottolenghi and Helen Goh. There are other worthy contenders too, but only so much time to write in one day. 

Now that I've got you yearning for more baking books to add to your library, I'll quickly mention that we have upcoming promotions for two great baking cookbooks: The Pastry Chefs Little Black Book by Michael Zebrowski and Michael Mignano and French Patisserie: Master Recipes and Techniques from the Ferrandi School of Culinary Arts by Ecole Ferrandi.

Winners of the JBF Cookbook Awards

 cookbook collage

Jane and Jenny are at the James Beard Foundation awards ceremony in New York City, and live-tweeted the winners of the JBF Cookbook Awards. The first announcement was in the American category, where The Sioux Chef's Indigenous Kitchen by Sean Sherman and Beth Dooley edged out Homegrown and The Lost Kitchen

It's no surprise that the comprehensive Modernist Bread: The Art and Science by Nathan Myhrvold and Francisco J. Migoya took home top honors in the Restaurant and Professional field. EYB Member favorite Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat by Samin Nosrat bested worthy competitors Christopher Kimball and Melissa Clark to take home the prize for best general cookbook. 

Joshua McFadden won in the Vegetable-Focused category with Six Seasons. This must feel good coming off the controversy with his IACP award being rescinded. I noticed a few tweets that said this win was "interesting" - I am not sure if they were implying that it was given to him because he lost the other award. Most EYB Members would agree that the honor is completely deserved; Six Seasons has earned superlative reviews in the EYB Library. 

Stella Parks is probably riding high right now, because her epic book BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts won in the Baking category over both Sweet by Yotam Ottolenghi and Helen Goh and The Sweet Spot  by Bill Yosses and Peter Kaminsky. This is a well-deserved victory although it would have been difficult for me to choose between BraveTart and Sweet - I love them both. 

Nopalito: A Mexican Kitchen by Gonzalo Guzmán and Stacy Adimando won in the International category. The Pho Cookbook by Andrea Nguyen took home the prize for best Single Subject book. Michael Twitty's The Cooking Gene bested rivals in the Writing category, and also won the night's biggest award when it was named Book of the Year. 

2018's inductee into the JBF Cookbook Hall of Fame is Betty FussellShe is the author of seven cookbooks, including The Story of Corn, I Hear America Cooking, and Food in Good Season. She specializes in American food and good home cooking, and her work has appeared in the New York Times, Vogue, Travel & Leisure, and other magazines.

You can see the complete list of nominees and winners in all categories on our JBF 2018 community page

The winner of Food52's 'The Piglet'

collage

2018's The Piglet cookbook competition may have been the best one yet. Sixteen amazing cookbooks (you can find the complete list here) went head-to-head in a bracketed contest, with the winners advancing to the next round. There were some tough calls along the way, and the usual criticism about the way the judges approached each book. 

The Piglet is different than most cookbook competitions in that there are no categories, which means that baking books competed directly against savory tomes and cuisine-specific tomes were matched up against more general volumes. It made for some interesting matches, and more than one call for a separate tournament for baking books (someone suggested The Piglet and The Tartlet as names). 

The Final Four, to borrow a phrase from basketball tournaments, were Night + Market versus BraveTart and Six Seasons taking on Kachka. In the latter competition, judge and writer Carmen Maria Machado, when faced with the task of choosing between two fantastics volumes, summed up what many of us feel about great cookbooks: "individual recipes have their value, but a cookbook is a conversation." She felt Kachka told a more compelling story, so it advanced to the last round. 

Choosing between BraveTart and Night + Market would be a daunting task for anyone due to both the disparity in genres and the quality of each book. Artist Kate Schelter's review garnered several negative comments because she chose to make substitutions in the recipes she made from BraveTart while playing it straight with the recipes from Night + Market, which she chose as the winner. 

This meant that the championship match was between Night + Market and Kachka, both worthy contenders. The judge, Lisa Lucas, is the executive director of the National Book Foundation and her review was a delight to read. Lucas felt that the volumes "feel like they are spiritually tethered in two homelands, which comes through in the cooking," adding "I felt both far away and totally at home while I cooked alongside these chefs and their gorgeous creations."

After describing her adventures in cooking from each book, Lucas found the choice difficult to make. Both cookbooks had provided delicious recipes, but Lucas gave the nod to the book that made the food come alive through the author's personal stories. Kachka is the winner of The Piglet 2018

These classic books are being overlooked by new cooks

Joy of Cooking

For many of us, learning to cook meant spending time with classic cookbooks like Mastering the Art of French Cooking, Joy of Cooking, The Fannie Farmer Cookbook, and others published between in the last 60+ years. All of these books share one trait: they are not lavishly illustrated. A few line drawings appear here and there to demonstrate a technique, but by and large the recipes have no accompanying images, unlike today's books that are chock full of luscious photographs. 

Because of the profound shift in publishing, due in part to the prevalence of gorgeous food photographs on the internet, the classic books that have taught several generations how to cook are being passed up by the most recent generation. Kitchen Arts & Letters has noticed this trend, and they've written about the phenomenon in their blog. The staff at KAL tries to match people with a book that will be right for them, taking into account their skills and ambitions, among other factors. When they recommend a classic book like those mentioned above, they often get a question similar to "How can I cook it if I haven't seen what it's supposed to look like when I am done?" Passing up these books just because they aren't replete with photographs means these cooks "are missing out on some of the most useful and insightful resources within their grasp," says the KAL staff. 

I admit to being seduced by stunning photography when buying a book. However, gorgeous pictures do not always translate into the best dishes. I've been let down by several recipes with beautiful pictures that don't live up to the ideal expressed in the photo. While having an idea of what the finished dish looks like can be helpful, some of the pictures can be downright intimidating.  When I was discussing this issues with a friend today, she said she specifically avoids looking at a photo when making a dish, because she does not want to feel disappointed if her food doesn't look as pretty as the image. She posited that she might like the food less if she compared it to an ideal that she could not replicate. 

Cookbooks without photographs will be in the very small minority going forward, but I agree with KAL that we shouldn't pass up books just because they are not brimming with artful pictures. In fact, some of my favorite recipes have been from books with few illustrations. Rose Levy Berenbaum's The Cake Bible has some photos in a few color pages in the center, but for the most part there are only a few black and white line drawings interspersed with the recipes. Many of them form the backbone of my cake baking endeavors. Even as new, admittedly gorgeous books find their way onto my bookshelves, I still turn to The Cake Bible time and again, and I wouldn't part with that book for anything. 

Is this the world's most expensive cookbook?

 Pizza from ScratchIt is not unusual for old and rare cookbooks to fetch handsome prices. Even some new cookbooks, like the multi-volume set of Modernist Cuisine, cost several hundred dollars. However, a recently released tome about pizza may be setting a record for the most expensive new cookbook. The extremely limited edition Pizza from Scratch (available through the NYC bookstore Kitchen Arts & Letters) is selling for a whopping $2,400 USD.

Pizza from Scratch is no ordinary book. Only 40 copies have been produced, and each one is handmade by artist David Esselmont. Esselmont's current passion for food and cooking have lead to a string of "food" books - visual narratives that include  Pizza from Scratch Taxi Driver Curry and his prize-winning  Chili: a recipe

For his latest work, Esselmont tells the story, in woodcuts and linocuts, of how he literally grew a pizza on his farm in rural Iowa. Wholly embracing the farm-to-table movement, he grows wheat, garlic, tomatoes and basil; designs and builds an adobe clay oven (scale plans are included in the book); gives instructions on how to make the dough, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese; fire up the oven, assemble the pizza and cook it.  "There is something magical about cooking in a wood-fired oven: the rolling flames, searing heat and tantalizing aromas are quixotic. If you've grown the ingredients, and harvested the tomatoes and basil that afternoon - the flavors will be out of this world," he says. 

Each of the 40 copies is hand printed from the original blocks. There are thirty-six images in the book, plus the plans for the pizza oven. Five volumes were bound in goatskin and have already been sold (for $4,800 USD each). All the images are available separately as individual prints. Printed in editions of no more than fifty copies they vary in price from $120 to $700.  You can learn more about the book at Kitchen Arts & Letters, and at the author's website

JBF Cookbook Award nominees announced

 cookbook collage

Today the James Beard Foundation announced the nominees for its 2018 Cookbook Awards and other food writing/media awards. It is always interesting to compare the JBF list to the IACP list to see how many books overlap between them. If a book has made both lists, it has to be one of the best of the year. In 2018, fifteen books appeared on both lists, including Member favorites BraveTart by Stella Parks; Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat by Samin Nosrat; Sweet by Yotam Ottolenghi and Helen Goh; Dinner: Changing the Game by Melissa Clark; The Pho Cookbook by Andrea Nguyen; and The Book of Greens by Jenn Louis and Kathleen Squires.

This year JBF switched up a couple of the categories; for instance 'Cooking from a Professional Point of View' became 'Restaurant and Professional', and 'Nonfiction' morphed into 'Writing'. We will not see any controversies in the JBF awards similar to what happened with Six Seasons at the IACP, as the JBF does not allow any staff or trustees to be considered for its awards.

Sometimes the category choices are puzzling. For example, On Vegetables: Modern Recipes for the Home Kitchen  by Jeremy Fox and Noah Galuten is in the 'Restaurant and Professional' category, while Six Seasons: A New Way with Vegetables by Joshua McFadden and Martha Holmberg - also written by a restaurant chef - ended up in  'Vegetable-Focused'. This placement comes despite the latter having a quarter of its recipes including fish or meat, while the former has no meat recipes at all.

Brushing away these minor inconsistencies, we see a strong list of contenders for the various categories. Sweet has a chance to redeem itself from the upset loss at IACP, although BraveTart will provide stiff competition. Likewise, the 'General' category features robust candidates as Christopher Kimball's Milk Street faces off against favorites Dinner: Changing the Game by Melissa Clark and Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat by Samin Nosrat.

A smattering of non-U.S. and internationally-published books vie for honors this year, including The Palestinian Table by Reem Kassis and the above-referenced On Vegetables (remember EYB Members get a discount on all Phaidon books), and The Beauty Chef by Carla Oates.

As is to be expected, many of the nominees were featured on Jenny's best of 2017 list, including  Homegrown: Cooking from My New England Roots by Matt Jennings and State Bird Provisions: A Cookbook by Stuart Brioza and Nicole Krasinski and JJ Goode, among others.        

At a ceremony in New York City on April 27, 2018, the JBF will announce the winners of the awards, along with the inductee to the JBF Cookbook Hall of Fame.  Jenny had the honor of being a judge this year. She and Jane will attend the awards, so watch this space for a report afterwards. See all of the nomineees on our James Beard Awards 2018 page. 

Fundraiser to save the Kitchen Witch

Kitchen Witch Cook Book Shop has been serving cookbook lovers for over 18 years in New Orleans. Their shop located in the historic Bayou Road/Broad Street corridor is struggling to keep their doors open. The good news is that in the next year many high profile businesses and entertainment venues are set to open. The bad news is that with no infusion of cash now they will be forced to close.

The owners have started a fundraiser to keep the beloved store open stating "we love our shop, our customers, and our dear retail neighbors.  This area is comprised of small businesses which are locally owned.  We are proud of them and proud to be a vital part of this community.  Anything you wish to donate will make a difference, from a dollar up.  No amount is too small, no amount is less appreciated!  Thank you, we are humbled and grateful by your support.  Debbie and Philipe at Kitchen Witch."

Historic brick and mortar shops are important to our book culture and anything the cookbook loving community can contribute is sure to help. Our cookbook store page lists these types of shops, be sure to visit them when you are in the area and please check out the fundraiser page for Kitchen Witch. 

 

IACP Cookbook Award winners

 IACP winning cookbooks

Jenny and Jane attended the International Association of Culinary Professionals (IACP) annual meeting in New York City. That means they were able to see the winners of the 2018 IACP Cookbook Awards  in person! The rest of us had to follow along on Twitter - and now we know the winners.

We've updated our IACP 2018 community page to note the winner in each category. The first prize announced was for the Julia Child First Book Award. It went to Samin Nosrat's Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat, which also nabbed best American cookbook honors. The Baking category winner shocked me - Candy is Magic by Jami Curl bested the odds-on favorite, Yotam Ottolengh and Helen Goh's Sweet.

Cheers to the Publican won the Chefs & Restaurants category, and The Blue Apron Cookbook took home the award for best compilation. In the Culinary Travel category Michael Harlan Turkel's Acid Trip: Travels in the World of Vinegar scored an upset victory over Joan Nathan's King Solomon's Table and Carla Capalbo's Tasting Georgia. King Solomon's Table did win in the International group, so Joan Nathan didn't go home empty-handed. In the Literary Food Writing category, Emily Kaiser Thelin won for Unforgettable.

Hello, My Name is Ice Cream by Dana Cree was named the best Single Subject tome for the year. Six Seasons by Joshua McFadden took home top honors in the General category and was named Cookbook of the Year as well. The People's Choice Award went to Barton Seaver's American Seafood, and Modernist Bread received the Jane Grigson Award. See all of the nominees and winners on our IACP 2018 community page

Food52's 'The Piglet' cookbook competition returns for 2018

 The Piglet 2018

Indexed website Food52 has just announced the competitors for its cookbook competition called The Piglet. Now in its ninth year, the contest pits sixteen books against one another in a bracketed tournament competition. Over the course of several weeks, each of the judges (who are top food writers, chefs, and celebrities) make dishes from two books and announce which book was the better of the two. The advancing book takes on the winner from another bracket, until there is a victor. 

The books in this year's competition are: 

Autentico by Rolando Berementi
Bangkok by Leela Punyaratabandhu
Bravetart by Stella Parks
Dinner: Changing the Game by Melissa Clark
Ducksoup Cookbook by Claire Lattin and Tom Hill 
Gather by Gill Meller
Kachka by Bonnie Frumkin Morales and Deena Prichep
Kaukasis: The Cookbook by Olia Hercules
King Solomon's Table by Joan Nathan
Night+Market by Kris Yenbamroong
Onions Etcetera by Kate Winslow and Guy Ambrosino
The Pho Cookbook by Andrea Nguyen
Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat by Samin Nosrat
Six Seasons by Joshua McFadden
Tartine All Day by Elisabeth Prueitt and Jessica Washburn and Maria Zizka
The Art of Flavor by Daniel Patterson and Mandy Aftel

The judges for this year's competition include food writer Bonnie S. Berwick of The Washington Post, actor Sarah Michelle Geller, Tim Gunn of Project Runway, novelist Kevin Kwan, celebrity cook Rachael Ray, and others. The complete list of judges is included in the announcement. 

If the photos that are side-by-side on the page indicate the matchups, it's going to be an interesting competition. It looks like some of the books that would be considered favorites will face off in the first round, like Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat pitted against Six Seasons and Dinner: Changing the Game facing off against BraveTart. The announcement does not state whether the photo pairings represent the first round of competitions, so the matchups could be different. 

Notably absent from the list (and mentioned in the comments section) were Sweet by Yotam Ottolenghi and Helen Goh, Dining In by Alison Roman and Smitten Kitchen Every Day by Deb Perelman. To those worthy-but-overlooked candidates I would add David Tanis Market Cooking by David Tanis and The Artful Baker by Cenk Sonmezsoy.

The overall winner of The Piglet will be announced on April 20, and the interim competitions will be published as they are completed. Good luck to all of the excellent authors on the list!

Seen anything interesting? Let us know & we'll share it!

Archives