If I don’t “love” a cookbook but don’t “hate” it either, I’ll get the Kindle edition (on sale, preferably) and dispose of the hard copy by selling it (or donating it to my local library).
I generally don’t like Kindle cookbooks, they’re no fun to browse and it’s almost like not having the book. However with Eat Your Books, it’s easier to keep track of the Kindle books as part of the collection and if the book is indexed, it’s possible to find the handful of recipes i might want to make from it.
Sometimes my criteria for not “loving” a cookbook are aesthetic. If a cookbook is poorly designed, has bad typography, or has the unfortunate two-color print scheme that was so popular a while back, for instance, and I’m not really that keen on the book itself, I’ll dispose of it and use the Kindle edition and Eat Your Books to keep it in my collection.
There’s nothing like a handsome paper cookbook though when you want to take something to bed!