Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone - Member Meeting Place - Eat Your Books

Forum

Welcome Guest! You can not login or register.

Notification

Icon
Error

Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone   Go to last post Go to last unread
#1 Posted : Thursday, March 27, 2014 11:15:19 AM(UTC)
Does anyone have the new Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone? I've been comparing the two to see whether or not I can give away the old edition. So far I've discovered that the Harissa recipe which I didn't care for has been revised and I'm anxious to give it a go again. I also found that the spicy chickpea purée that I adore has been changed to plain old hummus. No more directive to toast & grind your own spices. No more flecks of cilantro. Plus the addition of tahini, yuck. So disappointing. I'd love to hear everyone else's thoughts.
#2 Posted : Friday, March 28, 2014 11:49:13 AM(UTC)

Sorry you don't care for tahini, but it's pretty fundamental to actual hummus.


Why would you want to let go the original VCFE?

#3 Posted : Friday, March 28, 2014 5:11:21 PM(UTC)
Wow. Thanks for your reply ellabee. That's what I loved about the original spicy chickpea purée. It was not, nor did it pretend to be, hummus. As to the original edition, if it turns out to be really similar to the new one I thought I'd spread the love and give it to my mom so we could share recipe notes with one another. Would love to hear from anyone who is comparing the two editions. Looks like some great new recipes have been added that I can't wait to try.
#4 Posted : Friday, March 28, 2014 10:24:27 PM(UTC)

I've often thought that VCFE would be my one allotted "stranded on an island" cookbook.  I don't know why, then, I haven't gotten very excited about the redo.  I figure I will stand (or cook!) on the sidelines and see what other people think before making a move.  Don't think I will be giving up the original, even though it is starting to crack at the binding!

#5 Posted : Sunday, March 30, 2014 4:27:06 PM(UTC)
VCFE has been on my to get list for a while, but I haven't pulled the trigger yet. So I would eagerly look forward to hearing about differences between the two versions from anyone posting. (Hopefully you will Shannon!)
#6 Posted : Monday, March 31, 2014 6:43:45 PM(UTC)

Michael Ruhlman reviewed the book in Saturday's Wall Street Journal. Here is the link, but I don't know if you will be able to access since the paper has a paywall. So below the link, I pasted the part of the article where he got into specific details on the book. In the first part of the article he is mainly writing about Deborah Madison in general. He kind of made me want the book, even though I have the first one.


http://online.wsj.com/ne...ooking&mg=reno64-wsj


From Michael Ruhlman's review:


With "The New Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone," Ms. Madison shows herself to be a formidable teacher not just of vegetarian cooking but of imaginative cooking generally. Her braised fennel with pine nuts, goat cheese and arugula is a perfect example. Sliced fennel is browned in oil, then braised in water on the stovetop till tender. That's it (tasty just like that, with some salt and pepper). But add what she suggests—lemon zest, pine nuts, goat cheese and arugula—and you have a wonderfully complex and satisfying dish with little extra effort. Her basic vegetable stock is astonishingly rich, even meaty-seeming (thanks to the umami-giving nutritional yeast, a new ingredient to me).


The book begins with two chapters of basics, which are followed by 1,400 recipes (!) divided into 17 chapters, on such topics as sauces, appetizers, sandwiches, salads, soups from scratch, stews and sautés, pastas and dumplings, tarts and pizzas, eggs and cheese, breads, desserts. Oh, yes, and the longest one is "Vegetables." About 150 of the recipes are new, and all have been given some kind of note of introduction (previously lacking) and those that happen to be vegan are marked as such.


If you're after gorgeous food photography, this book is not for you. Otherwise I can't imagine a home cook who wouldn't benefit greatly from frequent immersions in "The New Vegetarian Cookbook for Everyone." One couldn't hope for a more encyclopedic volume on the plants we eat, or a broader spectrum of recipes.


Take another look—as I did—at tempeh. I didn't think any human, man or woman, chef or writer, could get me excited enough to give the dense, bland mat of fermented soy (often touted as a great meat substitute) another chance. Yet Ms. Madison's Indonesian Fried Tempeh intrigued me, and, aided by her simple peanut sauce—well, I didn't become a convert, but I can no longer dismiss tempeh out of hand, as I once did, and I could even see developing a liking for its dense bite and nutty back-flavor, in the same way that I, raised on Minute Rice, long ago grew to love the dense chewiness of brown rices.


That's the key to Ms. Madison's influence: She opens your mind, makes you see without prejudgment. Our cooking world, our country's home kitchens, need exactly what Ms. Madison is offering here—a heavily plant-reliant, diverse diet of food we cook ourselves—and she arrives with it seemingly in the nick of time. Again.

#8 Posted : Wednesday, April 2, 2014 10:59:32 PM(UTC)

Thanks for posting that review, Vickster.  My favorite cookbook is Deborah Madison's Savory Way, but somehow I missed the original version.  That review really makes me want VCFE even more.

#9 Posted : Friday, January 27, 2023 10:59:47 AM(UTC)
Glad I read this thread. Now I don't feel so bad about owning the original VCFE and not NVCFE.
#10 Posted : Monday, February 6, 2023 8:43:19 PM(UTC)
Interesting to happen on this old thread. I too have a copy with a broken binding from years and years of use and instead of buying a new one, I bought a 2nd (also secondhand) original edition. I have even evacuated from a wildfire with one of the copies (desert island, anyone?), which, of course, is full of my notes (pre-EYB). I have looked at the new edition and hesitated, because I actually didn’t like the design of it — the aesthetics! Having worked in book design in publishing I guess I have strong feelings… I’d prefer to buy a supplement to the old addition with all the new recipes but I want to keep using the one that I love.
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.