Obsessed with the Best: 100 Methodically Perfected Recipes Based on 20+ Head-to-Head Tests by Ella Quittner

    • Categories: Bread & rolls, savory; Quick / easy; Cooking ahead; American
    • Ingredients: salted butter; all-purpose flour; light brown sugar; baking powder; buttermilk; vodka
    show

Notes about this book

This book does not currently have any notes.

Notes about Recipes in this book

  • "B.E.C." bacon (aka chewy-crispy bacon)

    • EatinSnax on March 01, 2026

      This bacon was a bit of a song and dance to make. I was sure the result wouldn’t be worth the effort while arranging and rearranging the bacon into grid patterns. But then I ate it, and it was so delicious that now I can say it actually was worth it. The texture of the bacon really did turn out fantastic. Chewy and crunchy at the same time. Would I go to the trouble to make it again? Maybe, buy only for special occasions.

    • CaptainPantsless on March 14, 2026

      This was phenomenally simple and worked perfectly. I usually make bacon on a sheet pan in the oven for ease and because it eliminates the trouble of trying to fit many bacon slices in one pan, but it's annoying to clean a sheet pan full of grease. This method allows for more slices in the pan and the bacon benefits from the overlap. Genius. Will use this regularly.

    • john_0dr7c7 on April 14, 2026

      Best bacon I've ever made

  • Tall pot perfect poach ("The Mia")

  • Fluffy no-special-equipment pancakes

    • Emily Hope on March 16, 2026

      These were quite good -- tender and custardy on the inside, a bit crisp outside. They were a bit taller than the usual recipe I make (from an old The Best Recipe cookbook). R thought they were too sourdough-ish at first (they do have a lot of buttermilk), but that did not stop him (or his sister) from eating the entire batch over the course of the morning and afternoon. Note that it is fairly fiddly for a pancake recipe, requiring the making of a meringue base. It also called for frying then in clarified butter -- which I made from the remainder of the stick after removing what was called for in the batter. But honestly I'm not sure it made enough difference to the texture to repeat. I'm not sure if the ricotta adds enough to be worth it, either -- next time will probably try without, and also up the whole wheat flour to half.

    • john_0dr7c7 on April 12, 2026

      Exceptional pancake. Perhaps a bit more effort than required for a Sunday breakfast, but certainly worth it for a special occasion or a hosted brunch

  • Yeasted pumpkin spice pancakes

    • CaptainPantsless on March 14, 2026

      These are custardy soft on the inside, like a soft pumpkin bread. We liked them but I'm unlikely to bother with this many bowls very often. Really appreciate that Ella uses the full can of pumpkin, though. I'm so tired of using 1/2 cup of a can and not having a use for the rest!

  • Lacy chocolate chip handkerchief pancakes

    • CaptainPantsless on March 21, 2026

      For future: remember it uses two pans to cook. Cast iron works best.

  • High-low-medium soft-scrambled eggs

    • CaptainPantsless on March 20, 2026

      It's fine. Doesn't really work with an electric coil stove - takes too long to change temp.

  • Make me this breakfast sandwich

    • CaptainPantsless on March 20, 2026

      Absolutely stunning. Made green onion pancake variation from Mooncakes & Milk Bread as the base. Next time I'd make 3-4 larger pancakes instead of the standard 6.

  • Braised tomato-butter cabbage

    • reagan_dr0a1f on March 14, 2026

      Really enjoyed the cabbage cooking method and the flavors. Would personally cut the ginger amount in half at minimum maybe more. Was overpowering for the recipe.

    • CaptainPantsless on March 21, 2026

      Incredible. 3 people an entire head of freaking cabbage because this was so good. 10 out of 5 stars.

    • olympia_mhnhwe on May 13, 2026

      A little bit time consuming in the beginning, having to sear off the cabbage in batches and get both sides. But the end product was very good. The pan sauce was really tasty. Wish I had some nice crusty toast points to sop it up with.

  • Twice-cooked cabbage with anchovy and bacon

    • CaptainPantsless on March 20, 2026

      Wow. This was incredibly rich and delicious. I made this because had a ton of leftover chopped green cabbage to use up. Worked perfectly well.

  • Crispy smashed potatoes with insurance cheese

    • reagan_dr0a1f on March 14, 2026

      I mean how can you go wrong with Potatoes and Cheese! Definitely was delicious. Added finishing salt at the end for an extra finish.

  • Stuffed smashed potatoes

    • CaptainPantsless on March 18, 2026

      Yum! I could eat this filling straight out of the bowl. The instructions are a little confusing in steps 3-5. Cut the bottoms off the potatoes in step 3, then scoop the top of the other side & the innards out together in step 4. In step 5, you'll keep the side you gutted facing up and pop the bottom slice on top.

  • Maple-sesame caramelized cashews

  • Warm sub salad

    • megan_5cnj8x on February 27, 2026

      You need a massive salad bowl but so worth it!

    • CaptainPantsless on March 22, 2026

      Used Calabrian chili olives and subbed a spring mix w/arugala for the straight arugula (we have a hater in the house). It was perfect. Saved the remaining pesto for mixing with mayo and adding to sandwiches tomorrow.

    • CaptainPantsless on June 04, 2026

      Out of olives so I used some marinated artichoke hearts and pepperoncini. We've made this an unreal number of times now and it always slaps.

  • Vodka sauce paccheri

    • CaptainPantsless on April 09, 2026

      Made a half batch - best vodka sauce I've ever tasted. The author pulls a huge amount of complexity from a few ingredients.

    • CaptainPantsless on April 26, 2026

      Still magnificent. Made with paccheri this time and loved it. Each noodle was like cutting into a steak - so substantial. I'd double the calabrians next time. I think I did it by accident last time when I halved the sauce, haha. Missed the spice this time around.

  • Vodka sauce tomato soup

    • eclairea on March 11, 2026

      Delicious! Followed recipe shared in NYT Cooking, and it put me in the mood for pasta, haha. Only used 1/2 cup of cream and it was plenty creamy!

    • CaptainPantsless on May 18, 2026

      Phenomenal. I replaced the water and half of the cream with chicken bone broth. Since the broth has more body than the water, it didn't taste any less creamy. This tastes exactly like Ella's incredible vodka sauce, but spoonable.

    • rachel_ywqstg on May 26, 2026

      Delicious! Wonderful paired with bread. Creamy and just a little spicy.

  • Overachiever extra-browned butter bakery-worth CCCs

    • judygol on April 06, 2026

      Amazing chocolate chip cookie recipe. definitely high effort with the most effort full part being that after you’ve made the cookie dough you need to measure out the cookies on the baking sheet the baking sheet in the freezer four minutes bake them take them out of the oven. Bang the pan, round them with a glass then back in the oven for another minute. They really are delicious, but that might keep me from making them all the time.

    • Slapeti on May 01, 2026

      A lot of work and they pretty much tasted like with ones from the recipe on the bag of chocolate chips

    • john_0dr7c7 on May 04, 2026

      Absolutely delicious cookies, if a bit involved

  • Gooey malted cookie dough chocolate chunk bars

    • PBBrownie on May 28, 2026

      Yumm! The malt flavor became stronger after a day or two. These stayed extremely gooey as promised...almost too gooey for me! But will make again :)

  • Soft and tender cupcakes

    • booksandchow on May 10, 2026

      The wine in these is really good! Totally works with gluten free flour

  • Perfect buttery shortbread

    • Kfaber on May 14, 2026

      Some of the best shortbread bars I’ve ever eaten

  • Tahini date shortbread

    • Kfaber on May 17, 2026

      Love the tahini flavor in these cookies, and the addition of dates takes them over the top.

You must Create an Account or Sign In to add a note to this book.

Reviews about this book

This book does not currently have any reviews.

  • ISBN 10 0063357682
  • ISBN 13 9780063357686
  • Linked ISBNs
  • Published Feb 24 2026
  • Format Hardcover
  • Page Count 384
  • Language English
  • Countries United States
  • Publisher William Morrow

Publishers Text

A charmingly obsessive, visually stunning, thoroughly tested exploration of the best ways to cook and bake your favorite foods—featuring recipes that combine the smartest tips, tricks, tweaks, and shortcuts, and a series of essays from a 14-month round-the-world reporting trip—from Ella Quittner.

Some might think the “best” chicken means “most efficient without sacrificing juicy meat,” while others might think “best” is the one that you won’t be able to stop thinking about for fifteen years, no matter how long it takes in a sous vide bag. When writer Ella Quittner (former creator of Food52’s “Absolute Best Tests”) is cooking or baking something, she absolutely cannot rest until she’s tested every method she can, to arrive at the best result. Even if that means traveling to Tokyo to learn the trick to extra juicy tsukune for her tender meatballs, or driving through Emilia-Romagna to collect nonna-approved methods for her chewiest fresh pasta, or spending time in the Alabama black belt gathering intel from the pros for her flakiest biscuits.

In Obsessed with the Best, Ella walks you through the results of 24 head-to-head tests of cooking methods to help you find the perfect choice for your palate, plus the reasons behind her top results. From these building blocks, Ella shares more than 75 recipes, grounding you in minimalist techniques that maximize flavor, and sharing creative options as jumping off points for your own favorite flavors. Recipes include:

  • The Fluffiest No-Special-Equipment-Needed Pancakes
  • No Fail Perfect Poached Eggs
  • The Last Vodka Sauce You'll Ever Need
  • Foolproof Cheesy Smashed Crispy Potatoes and more than a dozen optimized veggies, like Tomato-Butter Braised Cabbage.
  • Entrées from Triple-Secret Tender Meatballs, One-Hour Roast Chicken, Opulent Slow-Roasted Chicken, and Poached Lemon-Butter Shrimp
  • Sweets like Overachiever Extra Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Malted Chocolate Chunk Cookie Bars, The Softest Yellow Cake, and Actually Doable Brown Butter French-ish Buttercream

Sprinkled with reports on people, places, or things obsessed with “the best”—be it a bacon evangelist from Iowa who flies annually all the way to Kofu, Japan, to throw a “Porktober Fest” in the middle of a seasonal celebration of samurai culture, or an international spin through different pasta-making methods from Osaka to Tuscany—Obsessed with the Best is precise, informative, personal, and fun in equal measure.

Other cookbooks by this author