Notes about Recipes in this book

• Maya's chocolate fudge cake with milk chocolate frosting

  • DJM on August 13, 2018

    The yield on this recipe is way off. It made 30 standard size cupcakes, not 15 as stated in the recipe. A friend used 2 9x13 cake pans to accommodate the amount of batter

• Carrot spice cake with cream cheese frosting

  • DKennedy on March 19, 2015

    According to 2015 Piiglet competition, this is the best Carrot Cake that the judge who reviewed ever ate. I made it and really liked the cake, but I think I prefer the Huckleberry GF carrot cake. The frosting is outstanding.

  • stockholm28 on June 06, 2015

    I made this based on the piglet review. This is a good carrot cake, although a bit sweeter than I prefer. I thought the cake was better on day two as it was less " Crumbly" and quite moist. I had some trouble with the icing. She heats cream cheese and butter in the microwave on low until they are soft and then mixes with powdered sugar and vanilla. My microwave only has one setting and the cream cheese mixed with butter initially had the texture of cottage cheese. It tasted fine, but the texture wasn't quite right.

  • mamacrumbcake on June 25, 2018

    This is a very nice carrot cake, easy to make and unfussy. The blend of spices is just right. The texture is surprisingly soft, tender, and not greasy for carrot cake. The cake tends to crumble easily since there is no gluten and no xanthan gum. You will want to eat it on a plate with a fork. Alice Medrich says you can bake this cake in 9” layers, but I think it might break apart when removed from the pan. I baked it in a 9x13 glass dish. By the way, the recipe says bake at 350 for 30 minutes and reduce to 325 for an additional 30 minutes. My cake was finished 10 minutes after reducing the temperature.

  • Frogcake on October 04, 2016

    Hands down this is the best carrot cake I've ever tasted. It's really moist, has a perfect balance of spices, and just gets better the following day. The rice flour and a little oat flour provides complexity of flavour and a lovely, delicate crumb. I thought it was excellent without any icing at all or just a sprinkle of icing sugar.

• Peach crumble

  • TrishaCP on August 29, 2016

    This was really delicious and received raves, though I would personally reduce or eliminate the nutmeg next time. The method of cooking the crumble topping separately kept it really crisp. I didn't have rice flour, so ended up using AP flour instead. I also changed the proportions to be half AP/half toasted oat flour, and I was satisfied with the result.

  • Acequiamadre.nm on July 29, 2018

    The crumble was way too sweet. Cooking separately was a good idea--next time reduce the sugar. Also, I made and used brown butter--makes it nutty and delicious.

• Classic ginger cookies

  • TrishaCP on December 13, 2015

    These are great-gingery (I also used crystallized ginger) and savory and pretty much everything you want a ginger cookie to be. I cooked them the minimum time so they would stay soft as I don't like crispy ginger cookies. My one complaint is that I felt like the oatmeal flour (I used a toasted version) is lost here against the bold ginger- if I hadn't baked them I wouldn't have known they weren't made with regular flour. (I guess that may be a plus for some.)

  • FJT on September 09, 2016

    Perfect ginger cookie! I halved the recipe as 50 cookies is just too much temptation. Easy to make as long as you chill the cookie dough for a few hours and delicious.

  • SLane on December 30, 2014

    I made this recipe this month & loved them. They are VERY gingery but also very delicious ! I used crystalised ginger and it was fine. They turned out a little soft & chewy but that was OK too.

  • helskitchenvt on July 04, 2016

    A really wonderful cookie. I used these in my restaurant as a gluten free alternative dessert, but so many non-gluten-free people demanded them that they just became the default ginger cookie. And in fact my most popular cookie.

• Apple crumble

  • eliza on May 05, 2017

    Quite good. I found the crumble mix a little too sweet, but otherwise liked it. I added some seeds for some of the nuts (sunflower and pumpkin seeds), and liked the change. Would make again with a bit less sugar.

• Oat sablés

  • AllAboutFood on April 10, 2015

    Excellent texture, mouth feel and taste. But I found these cookies at least 10 to 15% too sweet for my taste. Has anyone else experienced this? I am anxious to try the buckwheat sables too and many more recipes from this intriguing book. And perhaps one of the variations listed for the oat sables.

• Simple scones

  • FJT on August 30, 2017

    These had a nice flavour thanks to the oat flour, but apart from that everything went wrong. I don't have a stand mixer and used my food processor instead and that may be the root of the problems. However. the recipe says that the dough should be very stiff ... mine really wasn't despite weighing the ingredients carefully. The dough apparently can't be over beaten, so I kept going in the FP but the dough wasn't getting any stiffer and probably wasn't getting much air incorporated, so after about 6 minutes I gave up and tried to mould the dough into a log to refrigerate (difficult given its loose consistency). After two hours in the fridge the dough wasn't solid enough to cut, so I left it overnight. Not surprisingly these scones did not rise at all and were quite dense. Don't think I'll be trying these again!

• Chocolate sablés

  • FJT on December 05, 2016

    Very similar to a cookie my Mum used to make. These are not very sweet which is a good thing in my book. These were just fine, but didn't wow us. I may try the variation which includes chopped chocolate in addition to the cocoa next time round.

• Basic pancakes

  • stockholm28 on June 14, 2015

    I made the version with oat flour. These pancakes are a little more delicate than pancakes made with wheat flour so be careful when flipping.

  • Melyinoz on June 20, 2020

    I made the version with sorghum flour. You could definitely tell the pancakes weren’t made with wheat flour, but the taste was not unpleasant, just different. I imagine, like most things, sorghum pancakes would grow on me if I ate them regularly. The batter is thinner than previous wheat batters I have used, resulting in thinner pancakes.

• Coconut Key lime tart

  • swegener on June 22, 2015

    SO good! The coconut crust was a particular hit. It was a bit hard to cut, but tasted amazing! I topped it with whipped coconut cream and toasted coconut!

• White rice chiffon cake

  • mamacrumbcake on April 23, 2018

    This was quite nice—perfect Chiffon Cake texture with a delicate flavor. Not beautiful, though, as the cake does collapse a bit.

• Double oatmeal cookies

  • njp on April 07, 2017

    Made these with coconut oil instead of butter. They were delicious, but the coconut oil gets very hard after being chilled. Next time I'll try dropping the dough on cookie sheets first.

  • Frogcake on December 01, 2018

    So delicious. This recipe will be used habitually. I used parchment despite the note - the edges of the cookies were wonderfully caramelly crunchy! Absolutely necessary to chill the dough for at least an hour. I used a mixture of pecans and almonds, no raisins. Oh my, I am embarrassed to say that I could have eaten all of these cookies!

• Bittersweet teff brownies

  • e_ballad on June 02, 2019

    These do not hold a candle to Medrich’s famous brownies, despite really enjoying the flavour of teff. They are nonetheless very tasty, but not jawdroppingly good like her other recipe.

• Dark and spicy pumpkin loaf

  • Frogcake on October 07, 2016

    This is the third recipe I've tried in this book and so far I'm impressed. I made muffins here, which were quite savoury. Will be making these again and again. In place of raisins I threw in a quarter cup of each of chopped pecans and dried cranberries. We really loved the light, delicate texture of these muffins. I'm excited to try more rice flour-buckwheat flour and other flour combinations in this book.

• German chocolate cake

  • helskitchenvt on July 04, 2016

    The Carrot Cake from this book was featured in the Piglet Tournament as the reviewer's new go-to carrot cake, but my money is on this German Chocolate Cake. I really don't see how it could be better.

• Toasty pecan biscotti with hibiscus pears

  • Melyinoz on June 20, 2020

    I only made half this recipe, the toasty pecan biscotti, because the picture in the book caught my eye. I should start out by saying that the biscotti are good. If I made them again I think that I would cut down on the amount of pecans used by a 1/4 because it uses an awful lot and I couldn’t successfully incorporate all of the pecans into the mixture, which was a waste. The end product is biscotti which is littered with pecans and coated in granulated sugar, how could they fail to taste good? It is hard to determine the taste of the actual biscuit component of the biscotti because it is difficult to get a bite without pecans, but the overall taste is enjoyable.

• Banana muffins

  • Melyinoz on March 13, 2021

    These were ok. I found them to be too sweet for my taste. They took a little longer to cook than stated, and even then some muffins were undercooked, but I that says more about hot and cool spots in my oven than the recipe.

• Dark and spicy pumpkin bundt cake

  • jenburkholder on November 08, 2020

    Excellent recipe - have made as a loaf and as cupcakes (12). I sub in other dried fruit - raisins, dates, figs - whatever is around and needs to be used up. I have found that using Authentic Foods Superfine white rice flour gives it the absolute best texture and it doesn't sink at all in the middle (which happened with Bob's Red Mill flour). It's delicious either way, though. Great GF recipe that doesn't suffer for being GF!

  • Bebette on October 17, 2020

    This cake was a big hit, even with those without a gluten intolerance.

• Food52 by Edward Lee

  The 2015 Piglet Tournament of Cookbooks vs. Brooks Headley's Fancy Desserts

  Full review

• Food52 by Rosie Schaap

  The 2015 Piglet Tournament of Cookbooks winner vs. Dorie Greenspan's Baking Chez Moi

  Full review