Cook's Country Best Lost Suppers: More Than 100 Old-Fashioned Home-Cooked Recipes Too Good to Forget by Editors of Cook's Country Magazine

    • Categories: Stews & one-pot meals; Main course
    • Ingredients: Alaskan cod; celery; chicken broth; heavy cream; potatoes; bay leaves; frozen peas; all-purpose flour; buttermilk
    show

Notes about this book

This book does not currently have any notes.

Notes about Recipes in this book

  • Creamy chicken pan pie

    • barbara_p9wqqp on May 17, 2026

      I have been making this for years. Both the pastry and the filling can be made ahead of time and assembled closer to baking and serving. It is absolutely delicious and the pastry is flaky and crisp. Final note: this is my daughter’s favorite dish.

  • Funeral potatoes with ham

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      True comfort food. I've had similar dishes made with canned soup and canned mushrooms....this recipe is sooo much better! Nice fresh flavors and textures. We increase the cheese to 2 cups because we're big on cheese and I use panko crumbs because we never have cornflakes on hand.

  • Martini mac and cheese

    • FromScratch on October 20, 2025

      Made this as written, except subbed in whatever cheese I had on hand, plus more salt, and it was absolutely delicious. I also just soaked the noodles in warm salted water for half an hour instead of actually cooking them, and it was fine.

  • Oh my God chicken (Chicken fricassee with heads of garlic)

    • kbrooks on May 03, 2026

      Lots of work and the end result isn't worth the effort.

  • Hunter's chicken

    • cellenly on June 05, 2025

      Smoky paprika rice and chicken. You have to like paprika. The family likes it and we’ve made it several times and we like it best with much more garlic and more vegetables (which may change the intensity of paprika flavor if you add a lot more vegetables). Beware you need a lot of lead time because after you do the prep (maybe 15-20 min if I have someone slicing a lot of garlic for me) and cook (maybe another 15-20), then it’s a 40 min bake. Basically all said and done it’s 1.5 hrs.

  • Roast chicken with orange cream gravy

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      Really liked this. Made zero changes to the recipe. Note that the oven gets really smoky when cooking the chicken.

  • Pork chop scallop

    • dditchoff on April 27, 2020

      Make sure chops are thick or they will overcook

  • Saucy mustard beef steak

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      This is one of my husband's favorite dishes. I cut the beef into 2" rather than 1" cubes - it's a stew,not a soup! Also increased the onions to a cup and the garlic to 3 cloves. Added a dash of smoked paprika. It's good served over noodles, rice or mashed potatoes.

  • Chili balls

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      Not worth the time and effort. This is one of the few recipes in this book that no one liked.

  • International dateline chicken

    • kbrooks on May 03, 2026

      We didn't really like this.

  • Southern braised pork chops 'n' gravy

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      I rubbed the chops with a garlic herb rub early in the day and refrigerated them until ready to cook. We love the flavors in the gravy...it's awesome!

  • Glop

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      What's not to like about this dish. Quick and easy to prepare. It reminds me of a dish my mom made that she called "Stompf". I vary this with different cheeses,different colored bell peppers...occasionally a jalapeño.

  • Screaming noodles

    • emiliang on April 28, 2013

      Was okay. May be a good way to get the kids to eat spinach. Fast to prepare, but felt like it was missing something. May try adding some white beans to it the next time.

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      This was just OK. Like the previous note, it tasted like something was missing. Quite bland.

  • Creamy potato puff

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      A winner. Wouldn't change anything.

  • Sicilian meatloaf

    • kbrooks on May 22, 2024

      Absolutely wonderful! I also made an onion and mushroom gravy,which may have been a bit over the top, but we were also having mashed potatoes. Don't omit making the foil sling as this is a soft meatloaf. Keeps it intact when removing from the pan.

  • Delicate manicotti

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      Loved this. The simple tomato sauce doesn't overpower the flavor of the filled crespelle. I didn't make the crespelle recipe included because I have a favorite crepe recipe in another cookbook but made the sauce and filling exactly as written.

  • Outrageous gulyás

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      This was good but probably won't make again I've other goulash recipes that are better.

  • Aunt Cho's chicken with vinegar and onions

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      Yummy. The chicken turned out so flavorful and juicy. Great over rice.

  • Snowed-in potato hot dish

    • kbrooks on December 08, 2024

      Simple and so easy. This is a dish for a cold winter night or for one of those days when you don't have a clue what to cook....oh,wait...I have potatoes! And voila a comfort supper. I just add a big spinach salad to accompany.

  • New England boiled dinner

    • kbrooks on January 04, 2025

      Delicious! You can smell the lovely cooking aroma all afternoon. Perfect one pot meal for St.Patrick's Day.

  • Pennsylvania Dutch slippery chicken bott pie

    • Rinshin on January 17, 2019

      Very good noodles. Slippery with good instructions. The key here is rolling the dough very thin. This recipe calls for low heat for 25 min in the soup to cook the noodles and I tend to think it is the right method to keep the noodles tender. Loosely followed the rest using homemade chicken stock from rotisserie chichen bones and chicken meat. Used the vegetables per recipe but added a bit of tumeric for color and pinch of saffron. The taste from my early teens living in Pennsylvania Dutch area. Simple comfort food at its best.

  • Coke oven fried chicken

    • kbrooks on May 07, 2026

      OK but not the best fried chicken.

  • Maine blueberry grunt

    • emiliang on July 09, 2014

      Light and delicious, this is the perfect dessert for a summer evening, as it does not require you to fire up the oven. Made it several times. It is pretty much foolproof. Easy to halve the recipe. Used White Lily Self-Rising flour with great results.

  • Grandma Newman's rice pudding

    • kbrooks on November 03, 2024

      This is a very easy rice pudding, cooked in the oven with occasional stirring.. My husband asks for it often. He prefers it without the spices,but with the raisins, so that's how I make it.

You must Create an Account or Sign In to add a note to this book.

Reviews about this book

This book does not currently have any reviews.

Reviews about Recipes in this Book

  • Cheese Frenchees

    • Kate Cooks the Books

      ...a dish so sinful and glutenous and wrong that it will have to be judged by a special tribunal. My daughter simply said this was the best thing I have every made. She was stupefied with happiness.

      Full review
  • ISBN 10 1933615443
  • ISBN 13 9781933615448
  • Published Sep 01 2009
  • Format Hardcover
  • Page Count 224
  • Language English
  • Countries United States
  • Publisher America's Test Kitchen
  • Imprint America's Test Kitchen

Publishers Text

Building on the hugely successful Lost Recipes Contest of 2007 and the book it inspired, America's Best Lost Recipes, Cook's Country magazine asked home cooks to again participate in a project to preserve our country's culinary heritage. This time, readers from around the country were asked to send in recipes for their favorite family suppers.

Remember when a full-flavored, from-scratch dinner would bring everyone to the table? Whether the family gathered around a classic, rosy-pink roast beef with gravy, an old-fashioned tamale pie steamed in a Dutch oven, or a creative noodle casserole called Preacher's Delight with ground beef, tomatoes, and cream cheese, nothing could beat the flavor or comfort that came from a homemade meal. In an effort to preserve these old-fashioned meals, Cook's Country magazine asked its readers to submit their favorite dinnertime recipes and the stories behind them. Recipes were pulled from mothers', grandmothers', and great grandmothers' recipe boxes, and from a thousand submissions, our test kitchen tested and perfected the best to present here, in Cook's Country Best Lost Suppers.

For some readers, old-fashioned family dinners meant comfort foods like Pan-Fried Chicken with Milk Gravy or Creamy Chicken Pan Pie. For others it's their family's twist on an old classic, like a mahogany-hued, meltingly tender pot roast braised in coffee. Then there are the dishes of economy, quick-and-easy but still plenty big on flavor, like Chicken a la King, Clam Pie, and Creamy Chicken and Waffles.

Many dishes found in this book are quintessential, slow-cooked Sunday suppers that folks just don't make that often today, meals made maybe while the yard work was being done or the house was being cleaned, while others are creative family recipes you won't find anywhere else that pull together in a snap--Meat-za Pie, International Dateline Chicken, Cornbread Meatloaf. And there are numerous dishes that speak to our country's heritage, recipes with a story worth remembering, from regional favorites like Pennsylvania Dutch Slippery Chicken Bott Bie (a pot pie stew with handmade noodles) and the Midwestern favorite Cheese Frenchees (a deep-fried, crunchy-coated grilled cheese) to old-world classics brought through Ellis Island, like a creamy, rich beef goulash and classic Italian lasagna with handmade spinach noodles. Cook's Country Best Lost Suppers is a collection so appealing that it's sure to encourage families to once again enjoy dinnertime together.



Other cookbooks by this author